Serving the City Island area for 60+ years

Sit down at Johnny’s Reef, and prepare for our attentive staff to take care of you with subtle efficiency. You can expect a personal commitment to ensure you have the relaxing meal you deserve.


Johnny's reef is City Islands best-kept secret for casual, affordable dining.

Where the prices might change, but the Quality, never does!

With Johnny’s Reef, we make sure your experience comes with a check you can afford anytime you’d like a unique dining experience. Our affordable prices mean you can drop by any day of the week.

Johnny’s Reef

Our chef carefully selects only the freshest market ingredients to create our featured offerings and seasonal specialties. Johnny’s Reef takes a new approach to traditional favorites you’ll come to love.



At Johnny’s Reef, we carefully developed our menu to offer a wide array of options, from rich and savory, to light and refreshing. You’ll soon want to experience all the options wonderful menu offers.

You’ve tried the rest… Now try the Best!




Johnny’s Reef is proud to be a member of this wonderful community, and it shows in the special gatherings we regularly host. Our venue is also available for events, as well as catering services.